Table 8 Group 4: Measures with one source of validity evidence (n = 19)
| Measure | Study | Setting/Licensure Group | Source of Validity Evidence | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Content | Response process | Internal structure | Relationships to variables | |||
|
EBP Implementation Scale (35 studies) | [92, 93] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | ||
| [84] | Not specified/Not specified | √ | √ | √ | ||
| [115] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [104] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [105] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [101] | Home health/RNs | √ | ||||
| [86] | Acute /RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [85] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [102] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [107] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [106] | Acute, primary, not specified/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [117] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | √ | √ | |
| [90] | Acute, primary, not specified/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [96] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [98] | Acute/RNs, LPNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [112] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [91] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [87] | Acute/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [113] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [59] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [99, 100] | Acute/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [109, 110] | Acute/RNs, not specified | √ | √ | |||
| [118] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [119] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [97] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [89, 108] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [88] | Public health/RNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [116] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [95] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [94] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [111] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [50] | Acute/RNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [63] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [103] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [114] | Not specified/Not specified | √ | ||||
|
EBP Beliefs Scale (42 studies) | [92, 93] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | ||
| [84] | Not specified/Not specified | √ | √ | √ | ||
| [115] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [104] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [105] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [101] | Home health/RNs | √ | ||||
| [128] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [106] | Acute, primary, not specified/Not specified | √ | √ | |||
| [130, 131] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | √ | √ | |
| [117] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | √ | √ | |
| [86] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [85] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [102] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [107] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [90] | Acute, not specified/Not specified | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [96] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [127] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [112] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [98] | Not specified/RNs, APNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [132] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [83] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [91] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [87] | Acute/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [133] | Not specified/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [113] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [59] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [99, 100] | Acute/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [109, 110] | Acute/RNs, not specified | √ | √ | |||
| [118] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [119] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [97] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [89, 108] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [88] | Public health/RNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [129] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [50] | Acute/RNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [116] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [95] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [94] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [111] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [63] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [103] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [114] | Not specified/not specified | √ | ||||
|
Evidence-Based Practice Questionnaire (36 studies) | [30] | Acute, not specified/ not specified | √ | √ | √ | √ |
| [49] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [41] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [40] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [55] | Primary/RNs | √ | ||||
| [44] | Primary/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [33] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [64] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [62] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [48] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [57] | Primary/RNs | √ | √ | |||
| [53] | Acute, primary, long-term care/RNs | √ | ||||
| [58] | Acute/Not specified | √ | √ | |||
| [39] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [60] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | √ | ||
| [42] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [43] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [34] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | |||
| [66] | Not specified/Not specified | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [38] | Acute, primary, not specified/Not specified | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [35] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | |||
| [52] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [47] | Acute/Not specified | √ | √ | |||
| [54] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [56] | Acute/RNs | √ | √ | |||
| [65] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [31, 32] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [37] | Acute/Not specified | √ | ||||
| [59] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [50] | Acute, primary/RNs, LPNs | √ | ||||
| [45] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [61] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [46] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [51] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [36] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| [63] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
|
DEBPQ (6 studies) | [122] | Acute, primary, public health/Not specified | √ | √ | √ | |
| [123] | Acute/RNs | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [124] | Primary/RNs, LPNs/RPNs | √ | ||||
| [8] | Public health, home health/Not specified | No supporting validity evidence | ||||
| [125] | Primary, public health, home health/RNs, APNs | √ | ||||
| [126] | Acute/RNs | √ | ||||
| Modified Evidence-Based Nursing Education Questionnaire (1 study) | [74] | Acute, primary/APNs | √ | |||
| Self-developed measure by Barako et al. (1 study) | [77] | Acute/Not specified | √ | |||
| Self-developed measure by Gerrish et al. (1 study) | [81] | Acute, primary/APNs | √ | |||
|
Adapted Fresno Test (1 study) | [83] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Self-developed measure by Kim et al. (1 study) | [48] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
EBP confidence scale (1 study) | [31, 32] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Information literacy tool (1 study) | [59] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Modified Korean EBM questionnaire (1 study) | [134] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
EBP Attitudes Scale (1 study) | [31, 32] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Attitudes to Evidence-Based Practice Questionnaire (1 study) | [33] | Acute/Not specified | √ | |||
|
Nurses’ Attitudes Toward EBP Scale (1 study) | [137] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Single item measure for EBP knowledge (1 study) | [109] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
EBP Knowledge Assessment in Nursing (1 study) | [45] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||
|
Knowledge Assessment Test (1 study) | [66] | Not specified/Not specified | √ | |||
|
Core Knowledge Questionnaire (1 study) | [62] | Acute/RNs | √ | |||